Does Coffee Give You Jitters and Anxiety? Here’s Why Your Second Cup Should Be Matcha Instead

If your morning starts with a cup of coffee, you’re not alone. For many people, that first cup feels great—comforting, energizing, and familiar.
But it’s usually the second coffee that brings trouble.

That’s when the jitters, the anxiety spike, and the stress-induced crash tend to hit. If you’ve ever felt shaky, overstimulated, or suddenly overwhelmed after your second cup, it’s a sign that your nervous system has hit its caffeine limit.

The solution isn’t to give up caffeine entirely—it’s to replace that second cup with a smoother, more balanced source of energy: matcha.


Why the Second Coffee Causes Jitters and Anxiety

1. Your cortisol is already elevated from the first cup

Coffee triggers the release of cortisol, your body’s primary stress hormone.
Your first cup gives you a boost—but your second cup often pushes cortisol too high, which can lead to:

  • Anxiety
  • Restlessness
  • Increased stress
  • Irritability
  • Trouble focusing

2. Your body can't process caffeine that quickly

Caffeine can take up to 6 hours to metabolize. When you stack cups too close together, caffeine builds up in your system and overstimulates your nervous system—aka the jitters.

3. Afternoon crash territory

That second coffee is a big reason so many people feel drained, moody, or foggy later in the day.


Why Matcha Is the Perfect Replacement for Your Second Coffee

Matcha gives you energy—but not the kind that sends you into fight-or-flight mode.

1. L-theanine supports calm energy

Matcha naturally contains L-theanine, an amino acid that:

  • Reduces stress and anxiety
  • Promotes calm focus
  • Softens caffeine’s intensity

This is why matcha provides stable energy instead of the spike-and-crash pattern of coffee.

2. Slow-release caffeine = no jitters

Matcha’s caffeine is absorbed more gradually thanks to its antioxidants and amino acids.
This creates:

  • 4–6 hours of smooth energy
  • No shaky hands
  • No anxious heart racing

3. It prevents the afternoon crash

Replacing your second coffee with matcha gives you a gentle lift that keeps you steady instead of overstimulated. Most people notice they feel:

  • More focused
  • Less stressed
  • More emotionally balanced
  • More productive in the afternoon

How to Replace Your Second Coffee With Matcha

You don’t need to quit coffee—just swap the cup that causes the issues.

Morning:
☕ Keep your first coffee. Enjoy it.

Late morning or early afternoon:
🍵 Replace the second cup with matcha.

Try it for a week and watch what happens:

  • Anxiety decreases
  • Energy stays stable
  • Jitters disappear
  • Mood improves
  • No crash later in the day

Pro tip:

Ceremonial-grade matcha tastes smoother and blends better into lattes.
Pair it with oat or almond milk for a creamy, feel-good ritual.


Final Thoughts

If your second coffee leaves you feeling stressed, shaky, or anxious, it’s not your imagination. Your body is sending you a message.

Switching your second cup to matcha is an easy, effective way to enjoy calm, steady energy without giving up caffeine entirely. It supports your focus, helps regulate stress, and gives your nervous system a break—while still offering a delicious daily ritual.

Your morning coffee can stay.
Your second cup? Let matcha take over.

Back to blog